logo

Energy in the News

SearchRSS Feed

The Chapel Hill Herald - 2006-09-26

Editorial: Potential plant violations are our concern (new window)

Officially, the Shearon Harris nuclear power plant is in Wake County. That's its legal address. But really, it's next door.

As the crow flies -- or, more pertinently, as the wind blows -- the Chapel Hill-Carrboro area is less than 20 miles from the site of Shearon Harris. All of Orange County -- not to mention Chatham, Durham, Wake and Lee counties -- is well within the 50-mile radius of potential contamination if an accident were to happen at Shearon Harris.

And that means those of us living and working in this community should be very concerned about what is going on in that southwestern corner of Wake.

According to several nuclear power watchdog groups, what appears to have been going on are repeated and continuous fire code violations at the plant. The groups, which include the Durham-based NC Warn, say that for more than a decade Shearon Harris has delayed complying with changed federal fire prevention rules.

Progress Energy, which operates the plant, insists Shearon Harris is safe, there are no real fire code violations there and they are working toward technical compliance with regulations. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission, which oversees the plant, agrees that the plant is safe, and though Shearon Harris is not actually in full compliance, notes there haven't been any official fire protection violations at the site since 2004.

NC Warn and the other groups want the NRC to suspend Shearon Harris' operating license until the plant corrects the alleged violations or else to heavily fine Progress Energy. Last week, the watchdog groups took their argument to the local Assembly of Governments' semi-annual meeting; they found -- as they should have -- a receptive audience.

Officials from Chapel Hill, Carrboro, Hillsborough and Orange County agreed that the groups' safety concerns were legitimate and pledged their support. They promised to officially take up the issue at their next individual board meetings.

They understood, as should we all, that technical compliance is not sufficient. There are regulations for a reason. A fire accident at Shearon Harris would not be simply a technical glitch. It could be a catastrophe.

Local officials have an obligation to demand more stringent enforcement from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.